Business is ultimately about profit.  This principle forms the backbone of Taylor Law's Dispute Resolution and Avoidance service for Businesses...

Our busy schedules mean that we need our private lives to run smoothly.  This is our time to relax with family and friends.  We expect the best from our suppliers and service providers.   But this doesn't always happen.  When things go wrong Taylor Law are here to help...

TAYLOR LAW - Dispute Resolution Processes


Dispute resolution can be by adjudicative or consensual processes.

An adjudicative process is one in which a third party is asked to impose his decision on the parties in dispute. 
Litigation, arbitration, expert determination and adjudication are examples of adjudicative dispute resolution.

Consensual dispute resolution involves the parties agreeing an outcome voluntarily. 
Obvious examples are mediation and negotiation.

Litigation: Generally, there is a right to litigate a dispute by raising an action in court.  An action can be raised either in the sheriff court, or in the Court of Session.  Certain types of dispute can only be raised in the Court of Session.  There are also different procedures in each of these courts. 

In the sheriff court there is the Small Claims procedure for claims for payment, recovery of property or implement of an obligation, of a value up to £3,000.  Summary Cause procedure is used for claims which do not fall under the Small Claims procedure, up to a value of £5,000.  The most complex procedure is the Ordinary Cause procedure which must be followed for all claims of a value over £5,000.  There is also the Summary Applications procedure which is normally used for the enforcement or review of the decisions of public regulators.  Litigation may best be adopted where your opponent will not engage, where a right requires to be enforced, or where the dispute involves a question of law.  In addition, there are specific procedures for, Family actions, accident claims and, in some courts, for commercial disputes.

The Court of Session also has different procedures.  The default is the Ordinary procedure, but, again, there are specific procedures for example, for review of the decisions of public bodies (Judicial Review), for Family action, and for accident claims.  In addition there is a specific procedure for the resolution of commercial disputes.  This procedure is becoming increasingly popular amongst commercial clients, because of its speed and pragmatism.  The intention is that the same judge will preside over each stage of the process.  He will take a more active role in resolving the dispute.  It is best used where the issues between the parties are focused.

Arbitration:
Arbitration is, essentially, litigation by agreement.  The parties agree, before or after the dispute arises, to arbitrate rather than litigate.  The parties may agree on the procedure to be followed, but otherwise the Arbitration (Scotland) Act 2010 will govern the arbitration.  If the parties do agree to arbitrate, litigation may not be possible.  The main advantages to arbitration over litigation are that the dispute may be resolved in private and someone who has specialist knowledge of the subject matter of the dispute may be appointed to resolve the dispute.  Arbitration has existed for centuries, but the 2010 Act has led to some excitement in Scotland about its future use and development.

Expert Determination: 
This procedure is usually faster than litigation or arbitration.  Again the parties can decide the procedure to be followed and can agree that the process will remain private.  But there are some key differences between arbitration and expert determination.  For example, an expert can use his own knowledge and experience to reach his decision, but cannot determine a question of law.  Expert Determination is best used where there is a discrete argument of fact between the parties, such as the quality of works undertaken.  Expert Determination can be used in the context of a litigation.

Adjudication:
Adjudication is also a fast track method of dispute resolution.  It usually takes between four and eight weeks.  It is akin to arbitration.  However, unlike other forms of dispute resolution, the decision reached by the adjudicator is temporary and may be overridden by a subsequent arbitration or adjudication.   The parties may agree to adjudication before or after a dispute has arisen.  In relation to certain construction projects there may be an entitlement to refer a dispute to adjudication under the Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act 1996.  Because of its speed and because the adjudicator may be a specialist in construction, it is a popular method of resolving disputes in the construction sector.

Mediation:
The danger with adjudicative processes of dispute resolution is that the parties become polarised.  Long term relations may therefore be damaged.  Mediation is not about a third party imposing a decision.  It is about facilitating the parties to come to their own agreement.  Mediation can therefore allow issues beyond the dispute itself to be taken into account.  Innovative solutions can be found to maintain relations going forward.  A mediation can be established quickly and normally takes a day of meetings to conclude.  The mediator will listen to the respective parties' positions, concerns, or motivations and can be given information in confidence.  He will move between the parties to bring them together in agreement.  Nothing is binding, or can be relied upon in subsequent proceedings, until an agreement is reached.  Depending on time pressures, mediation may be worth engaging in before following adjudicative dispute resolution procedures.  Indeed, in England, there may be consequences in the award of expenses by the court if mediation has not been attempted.  Mediation is useful as much in commercial disputes as it is in Family disputes.

Negotiation:
Negotiation is mediation without the mediator.  It involves the parties, or their representatives seeking to resolve the dispute in a commercial, sensible manner, to avoid the risks and costs of other methods of dispute resolution.  Negotiation is an art which requires skill and experience.  The kind of skill and experience that Taylor Law can offer through the years involved in dispute resolution of its personnel.

Dispute Avoidance: Disputes are expensive. They cost money, time and emotional strain whether in business or private life. The likelihood of disputes arising, and the costs involved in resolving disputes that do arise can be reduced.  The most obvious method of doing so is to seek to ensure that the terms of any contract or agreement are clear, precise and unambiguous.  Provisions about dispute resolution procedure, which is tailored to fit with the scope and nature of the contract or agreement should also be included.  Taylor Law can assist you in avoiding or reducing the cost of dispute by reviewing your contracts, agreements, standard terms or by assisting you at the tender stage. 

 
dispute resolution

 

If you would like our assistance please contact us.



Read about the latest developments at Taylor Law

Read the latest business news from the BBC

Hidden company owners to be revealed
Companies will be forced to declare their true owners on a public register in a move to tackle corruption, Business Secretary Vince Cable says.
Businesses celebrate Queen's Awards
Jaguar Land Rover is among a list of more than 100 winners of Queen's Awards for their success in international trade.
Two government agencies quit CBI
Scottish government agencies Scottish Enterprise and Visit Scotland have quit business lobby organisation CBI after it formally backed the campaign against Scottish independence.
Japan's trade deficit quadruples
Japan's trade deficit quadrupled last month compared to March 2013, as export growth slows and energy imports continue to rise.
Quango chair resigns over bankruptcy
A businessman appointed by the prime minister to head a multibillion-pound quango steps down after it was revealed that he was bankrupt.
Garden centres 'want' Easter choice
The government is urged to end restrictions that prevent many garden centres in England and Wales from opening on Easter Sunday.
HMRC 'plans to share personal data'
Taxpayers' personal financial data could be shared with private firms and researchers, Revenue & Customs says, despite concerns over privacy and security.
'Rogue directors' crackdown planned
People convicted of commercial crimes overseas could be banned from running UK firms in an attempt to tackle "rogue directors", Business Secretary Vince Cable says.
Giorgio Armani settles tax dispute
The fashion house Giorgio Armani pays 270m euros (£222m; $374m) to the Italian authorities to settle a tax bill.
Ex-BP worker fined over shares trade
A BP employee who oversaw the cleanup of the Deepwater Horizon oil spill in 2010 agrees to settle a charge of insider trading.
Barnes & Noble founder offloads $64m
Barnes & Noble chairman trims his stake in the bookstore company to 20% by selling shares worth $64m.
Pensioners could get death estimate
Retirees could be told how long they are likely to live after stopping work, says pensions minister Steve Webb.
Co-op Group reports £2.5bn loss
The Co-operative Group reports losses of £2.5bn, the worst results in its 150-year history, after what its chief executive calls a "disastrous" year.
Lamb takeaways 'often another meat'
Takeaway owners are to face a new testing programme, after a watchdog found nearly a third of lamb takeaways it checked contained a different meat.
Anglo Irish bank pair found guilty
Two former Anglo Irish bank chiefs have been found guilty of making loans designed to illegally prop up the bank's share price.
UK housing market 'shows resilience'
The "resilient" UK housing market recorded another increase in mortgage lending in March, according to a lenders' group.
Tencent brings Candy Crush to China
China's internet giant Tencent will launch the popular Candy Crush game on the mainland in partnership with the game's creator King Digital Entertainment.
Free jail-built bikes for jobseekers
Jobseekers in Derby will be given free bikes refurbished by prisoners in a bid to help them find work.
New teachers 'can't risk mortgages'
A teachers' union leader says young teachers are shying away from taking out mortgages because of uncertainty over their future earnings.
Wage rises catch up with inflation
After nearly six years of falling real wages, rises in weekly earnings have finally caught up with inflation, according to the Office for National Statistics.
'Shocking' rise in use of food banks
Hundreds of thousands more people are turning to food banks to stop themselves from going hungry, says charity the Trussell Trust.

Visit our social media websites

facebook icon twitter icon linkedin icon youtube icon

solicitors and consultants
lawyers fife

We offer specialist assistance and knowledge to solicitors and other professional consultants, whether in a large city firm or a small rural practice.  We can do so in a variety of ways:

more
Taylor Law is the trading name of Taylor Law Limited,
Registered No. SC355902 | Registered Office: 3 Castle Court, Carnegie Campus,
Dunfermline, Fife, KY11 8PB | Regulated by the Law Society of Scotland